Questions from listeners concerning pharmakia and the vaccine mandate; should I stay or leave the Watchtower? And a question about the importance of gold. The last few podcast are available on Apple Podcasts
Last edited:
Tricky one. Isn’t Watchman himself in the same position?Excellent! I do have a question...On your point about whether to stay or leave in regards to the meetings....I think your answer was spot on except I don't know how that would work in my situation. I have been disfellowshipped for 20 years. In order to go back and go to meetings and be of encouragement to others I would have to be reinstated. I know it would be impossible for me to be reinstated in my now being awakened to Truth about the Truth. I now read the Bible more now and I have more love and thrust for knowledge than I ever have. Because of recent world events those who I witness to can make since of Truth more so now than any time when I was in the ministry. Am I missing something...where does that work for my situation?
Even if I were reinstated...my personality is one that...I could not be quite about the Truth of the organization. I couldn't let go. I would demand an accounting.The reality is, it is more difficult to come back than it is to stay.
Yes but surely, you lead by example.The reality is, it is more difficult to come back than it is to stay.
It’s difficult isn’t it, I agree that if your not attending. meetings you are seen as spiritually weak etc. in reality the GB has made it difficult for those that see what’s happening. Mask mandates at the meetings, zoom attendance you don’t get the same association, field service resuming directing people to a JW.org it all doesn’t sit well.The reality is, it is more difficult to come back than it is to stay.
I agree ( if I am reading your comment correctly ) -In, my very personal opinion- one of the most difficult things would be the requirement to direct people to jwdotorg and the strict obedience to the gb.It’s difficult isn’t it, I agree that if your not attending. meetings you are seen as spiritually weak etc. in reality the GB has made it difficult for those that see what’s happening. Mask mandates at the meetings, zoom attendance you don’t get the same association, field service resuming directing people to a JW.org it all doesn’t sit well.
Welcome to the forum SeaGull. Look forward to your thoughts.I agree ( if I am reading your comment correctly ) -In, my very personal opinion- one of the most difficult things would be the requirement to direct people to jwdotorg and the strict obedience to the gb.
[ which in my view is promoting idolatry] Having just recently [ this past year] - realized how misleading and controlling the gb is, - how could I in good conscience try to put innocent people in a situation like that? Not to mention the difficulty of commenting truthfully, and keeping quiet, when the wt article is misleading. Personally, I would just not be able to carry it off.
not really.Yes but surely, you lead by example.
to direct people to apostate information such as is found on jw dot org is unconscionable.how could I in good conscience try to put innocent people in a situation like that?
I think it is best to give people the same opportunity we have had.to direct people to apostate information such as is found on jw dot org is unconscionable.
I think it is best to give people the same opportunity we have had.
Excuse me Chloe, I'm a little thick from time to time but what do you mean by this?The fact is that wading through all this devils advocate stuff isn’t easy.
I feel ya. Apparently Truth is a journey and not a destination-in this life anywayThe fact is that wading through all this devils advocate stuff isn’t easy.
The idea of returning to meetings and field service in the light of the governing bodies support of covid vaccines is extremely difficult for many. Watchman is advocating both meetings and service which leads one to feel he will follow his own advice. Or maybe not. Playing devils advocate by championing an unpopular course of action can sometimes help ones to solve a moral dilemma but it is hard to swallow.Excuse me Chloe, I'm a little thick from time to time but what do you mean by this?
I understand what Robert is saying, but it's not just their support of these inoculations that are obviously causing so much illness and death, and which aren't effective at all, but their protection of sexual predators which makes it so difficult for many to stomach supporting the GB in any capacity.The idea of returning to meetings and field service in the light of the governing bodies support of covid vaccines is extremely difficult for many. Watchman is advocating both meetings and service which leads one to feel he will follow his own advice. Or maybe not. Playing devils advocate by championing an unpopular course of action can sometimes help ones to solve a moral dilemma but it is hard to swallow.
Your entire post is right on the money but I particularly resonate with the above thought. Christianity was not designed to be an "organization" akin to the Jewish "God's People" system. The anointed make up the "house of God". Jehovah deals with us as individuals and not an org any more. Many scriptures to prove this point, just ask if desired to see.And at Matt 18:20, when addressing a situation where a sinner must be corrected first by a few and then by the congregation if needed, Jesus said wherever two or three are gathered in his name, he is there.